UN Immigration Detention · GCR → Ministry of Justice
법무부, 헌법재판소
Echo patterns are similarity-based hypotheses, not proof of causation. Open the sources and evaluate the linkage yourself.
Evidence Scorecard
A single score cannot prove an echo. This card triangulates semantic, temporal, and linkage evidence.
Computed with intfloat/multilingual-e5-small multilingual embeddings. Display score is a calibrated mapping of the raw cross-lingual cosine (0.771); higher means closer meaning. Reflects semantic similarity, not proof of causation.
Could also be…
- •Parallel domestic policy development is possible.
- •Industry or market pressure may have driven similar language.
- •A common external shock (e.g., financial crisis, pandemic) could explain parallel adoption.
Timeline of the echo
7 year lagFrom date field: 2018 GCR → 2023 court → legislative process · 2018–2025
Interrogate the Evidence
Answers are rendered directly from this record’s own curated fields — nothing is generated.
Bprobable echo · 80%
- SemanticStrong semantic alignment
- TemporalGlobal precedent precedes Korea
- LinkageOfficial Korean agency source + concept alignment (no explicit citation recorded)
Matched concepts: alternatives to detention (ATD) ↔ 구금 대안; non-penalization of asylum seekers ↔ 난민 보호 범위
Cross-lingual similarity 26/100 (multilingual e5 embedding) — a computed signal, not proof.
Similarity type: soft law + litigation channel
Matched Concepts
2 pairsSuggested Concepts
Auto-aligned concept pairs surfaced by our Concept Suggester engine. Shown as supplementary leads — the curated matches above are the authoritative set.
Agenda Arc
CuratedGlobal purpose, Korean purpose, and precursor stages. Reasoning echo is discourse observation — not proof of coordination.
GCR (nonbinding) and UNHCR detention guidance emphasize last resort and alternatives to detention.
「출입국관리법」 제63조 등에 대한 헌법재판소 결정 및 국회 입법·정부 시행(공문·헌재·국회 자료 기준).
헌법재판소 — 「출입국관리법」 제63조 등에 대한 헌법재판소 결정 및 국회 입법·정부 시행(공문·헌재·국회 자료 기준).
Global purpose leads with “GCR (nonbinding) and UNHCR detention guidance emphasize last resort and alternatives to detention.”; Korean purpose leads with “「출입국관리법」 제63조 등에 대한 헌법재판소 결정 및 국회 입법·정부 시행(공문·헌재·국회 자료 기준).”. Framing comparison only.
UN · UNHCR
2018 GCR → 2023 court → legislative process
- Soft lawGlobal2018UNGCR
2018 GCR
Primary source - StageGlobal2023UNcourt
2023 court
- Soft lawKoreaUNlegislative process
legislative process
Primary source
UNHCR Global Compact on Refugees promotes alternatives① to detention (ATD) and non-penalization of asylum seekers②.
헌법재판소 구금·출입국관리법 판결: 구금 정당성·난민 보호 범위②는 해당 결정문을 기준으로 확인.
Echo Strength
Influence Mechanism
2018–2025
soft law + litigation channel
Sources
Related Patterns
UNHCR Refugee Convention → Korea Refugee Act
1951 Refugee Convention → Korea Refugee Act (난민법)
Judicial Independence Under Pressure
UNHCR Asylum Procedures → Korea Refugee Status Determination
UNHCR #IBelong Campaign → Korea Statelessness Prevention
UNHCR Resettlement Program → Korea Refugee Resettlement Pilot
ESG / Climate Disclosure
Soft Power & Cultural Export (K-content)
Gender Policy / Women's Rights Oscillation
ILO Core Conventions → Korean Labor Law Reform
Automotive Cybersecurity (UN R155 / WP.29)
UN 2030 Agenda / SDGs → K-SDGs & Sustainable Development Basic Act
Stockholm / Rotterdam Conventions → Korea Persistent Organic Pollutants Act
Basel Convention → Korea Transboundary Hazardous Waste Act
UN Convention Against Torture (CAT/OPCAT) → Korea
CEDAW → Korea Framework Act on Gender Equality
Outer Space Treaty / UN COPUOS → Korea Space Development Act & KASA
UN Arms Trade Treaty → Korea Foreign Trade Act (strategic items)
UN Global Digital Compact → Korea Digital Bill of Rights
UN Arms Trade Treaty → Korea Arms Export Control
Networked Global Governance Matrix
Deepfake Regulation (2024-2025)
CAT Article 4 (Criminalization of torture) → Korea Criminal Act & Administration of Criminal Detention Act
AI Misinformation Laws
ESG Disclosure & Green Finance (Banks)
Korea AI Framework Act (2026)
EU CBAM & Korea Response (2026)
ESG Disclosure Mandate (ISSB-aligned)
Nuclear Energy Policy Oscillation
Media Consolidation / Press Freedom
Platform Content Moderation (Network Act)
Supply Chain Due Diligence (CSDDD)
Genome Editing & LMO Biosafety (Cartagena Protocol)
IMO Ship Recycling Convention → Korea
ICAO Aviation Safety & Open Skies
KASA & Space Development Promotion Act
Hydrogen Roadmap & IEA Clean Energy Transition
UNESCO Cultural Heritage & Intangible Heritage (Korea Heritage Service)
WHO Mental Health & Suicide Prevention Framework
UNESCO SDG4 & AI Digital Textbooks (Education)
UNFCCC Paris NDC & Korea Carbon Neutrality Act
UNESCO AI Ethics Recommendation → Korea AI Basic Act
ILO Convention 190 (Violence & Harassment) → Korean Workplace Harassment Law
WHO Pandemic Agreement (WHA78) → Korea Infectious Disease Law
EU–Korea Framework Agreement → Political / Global Governance Cooperation
UN Civil Society Participation ↔ Korea Nonprofit Civil Society Registration
CBD / Kunming-Montreal Framework → Korea Biodiversity Act
EU ETS → Korea Emissions Trading Scheme (K-ETS)
UN CRC → Korea Child Welfare & Child Abuse Punishment Acts
CITES → Korea Wildlife Protection & Management Act
Hague Apostille Convention → Korea Document Authentication
Hague Child Abduction Convention → Korea Implementation Act
ICAO SARPs (Chicago Convention) → Korea Aviation Safety Act
Minamata Convention on Mercury → Korea Mercury Management
Sendai Framework (UNDRR) → Korea Disaster & Safety Management Act
UNCITRAL Cross-Border Insolvency Model Law → Korea Debtor Rehabilitation Act
Chemical Weapons Convention (OPCW) → Korea CW/BW Prohibition Act
UNFCCC Paris Agreement Article 6 (Carbon Markets) → Korea Emissions Trading Scheme
UNFCCC Global Stocktake (GST) → Korea Carbon Neutrality Framework Act
UNFCCC Global Goal on Adaptation (GGA) → Korea National Climate Adaptation Plan
UNFCCC Technology Mechanism → Korea Environmental Technology & Industry Support Act
UNFCCC Gender Action Plan → Korea Framework Act on Gender Equality
CBD Nagoya Protocol on ABS → Korea Genetic Resources Access and Benefit-Sharing Act
CBD Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety → Korea LMO Transboundary Movement Act
Basel Convention (Waste Management Framework) → Korea Waste Management Act
Basel Convention Plastic Waste Amendments → Korea Circular Economy Act
Basel Convention E-Waste Technical Guidelines → Korea E-Waste Recycling Act
Stockholm Convention (POPs Regulation) → Korea Persistent Organic Pollutants Management Act
Stockholm Convention (PFAS Regulation) → Korea Chemical Substances Management Act
IMO Ballast Water Management Convention → Korea Marine Environment Management Act
IMO Polar Code (Ship Safety in Polar Waters) → Korea Maritime Safety Act
IMO MARPOL Convention → Korea Ship Safety Act
IMO Sulphur 2020 (Global Sulphur Cap) → Korea Eco-Friendly Ships Act
IMO Anti-Fouling Systems Convention → Korea Ship Navigation Act
ICAO Aircraft Noise Standards (Annex 16) → Korea Airport Noise Prevention Act
ICAO Long-Term Aspirational Goal (LTAG) → Korea Aviation Business Act
ICAO Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) → Korea Carbon Neutrality Framework Act
ICAO Annex 17 (Aviation Security) → Korea Aviation Security Act
UN SDG 7 (Affordable and Clean Energy) → Korea Energy Act
IPCC WG3 (Climate Mitigation) → Korea Energy Use Rationalization Act
IPCC AR6 (Energy Systems Transition) → Korea Urban Gas Business Act
UN Cybercrime Treaty → Korea Cybercrime Investigation Framework
UNCITRAL CISG → Korea International Sale of Goods Act
UNCITRAL Model Law on Arbitration → Korea Arbitration Act
CRC Optional Protocol on Sale of Children → Korea Child Welfare Act & Act on Protection of Children and Youth against Sex Offenses
CRPD Article 9 (Accessibility) → Korea Disability Anti-Discrimination Act & Convenience Promotion Act
CEDAW General Recommendation 35 (Gender-based violence) → Korea Framework Act on Prevention of Violence Against Women
CEDAW Article 7 (Political participation) → Korea Gender Equality Act & Political Parties Act
FATF Proliferation Financing → 대량살상무기확산자금조달금지법
UNDRR Sendai Framework → 재난안전관리기본법 (재난위험경감)
UNDRR Sendai Framework Monitor → 한국 재난통계 및 지표체계
UNDRR Early Warnings for All → 한국 조기경보시스템
UNDRR National Platform → 한국 국가재난안전포털
IAEA Nuclear Safety Standards → Korea Nuclear Safety Act
IAEA Fusion Energy / ITER → Korea Nuclear Energy Promotion Act
IAEA Nuclear Energy / Peaceful Uses → Korea Power Development Promotion Act
UNODC/UNTOC Protocol on Human Trafficking → Korea Criminal Act & Act on Prevention of Human Trafficking
UNFCCC Paris Agreement NDC → 탄소중립기본법 시행령 (Carbon Neutrality Framework Enforcement Decree)
ICAO Annex 19 Safety Management → 항공안전법 시행령 (Aviation Safety Enforcement Decree)
Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) Guidelines → 원자력안전위원회·전략물자관리원 핵비확산 고시 (NSSC Nuclear Export Control Notice)
UNDRIP (UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples) → Korea's Traditional Community & Cultural Heritage Policies
IAEA GSR Part 4 (Safety Assessment) → 원자력안전법 시행령 (Nuclear Safety Enforcement Decree)
ITU Radio Regulations (RR) → 방송통신위원회·국립전파연구원 전파설비 고시 (KCC Radio Equipment Notice)
IAEA GSR Part 3 (Radiation Protection) → 원자력안전위원회 방사선안전 고시 (NSSC Radiation Safety Notice)
CRPD Article 12 (Equal recognition before the law) → Korea Adult Guardianship System (Civil Code)
IMO SOLAS Chapter XI-2 (ISPS Code) → 해사안전법 시행령 (Maritime Safety Enforcement Decree)
Green Taxonomy / K-Taxonomy Classification
AI Transparency & Generative AI Labeling
EU REACH / GHS → Korean K-REACH & Chemicals Control Act
UN Anti-Corruption Convention (UNCAC) → Korea Conflict-of-Interest Act
UN CRPD → Korea Disability Anti-Discrimination Act
UN Global Plastics Treaty (INC) → Korea Plastic Reduction Policy
WIPO Marrakesh Treaty → Korea Copyright Act (accessible works)
UN Convention vs Transnational Organized Crime (Palermo) → Korea
UNFCCC Just Transition → Korea Employment Policy Framework Act
UNFCCC Climate Finance (GCF/Standing Committee) → Korea Environmental Policy Framework Act
UNCLOS Part XII (Marine Environment Protection) → Korea Marine Environment Management Act
Rotterdam Convention (PIC Procedure) → Korea Chemical Registration & Assessment Act
Minamata Convention (Mercury-Added Products) → Korea Environmental Health Act
SAICM / Global Framework on Chemicals → Korea Consumer Chemical Products Safety Act
ILO/WHO Asbestos Convention → Korea Asbestos Safety Management Act
UN Energy Compacts → Korea New & Renewable Energy Act
UNFCCC Renewable Energy Workstream → Korea Electric Utility Act
UN Energy / Hydrogen Economy → Korea Hydrogen Economy Act
UNFCCC Energy Sector Mitigation → Korea Petroleum Business Act
UNCAC Article 33 (Protection of whistleblowers) → Korea Public Interest Whistleblower Protection Act
UNCAC Chapter II (Preventive anti-corruption measures) → Korea Improper Solicitation and Graft Act (Kim Young-ran Act)
UN Framework Convention on International Tax Cooperation → 한국 국제조세 협력 체계
IMO MARPOL Annex VI (EEDI/EEXI) → 해양환경관리법 시행령 (Marine Environment Enforcement Decree)
Semantically Related
Closest patterns by multilingual embedding (e5) — conceptual similarity beyond shared keywords. A computed signal, not a sourced claim.
UNHCR Asylum Procedures → Korea Refugee Status Determination
Immigration
Networked Global Governance Matrix
Rights & Anti-corruption
1951 Refugee Convention → Korea Refugee Act (난민법)
Rights & Anti-corruption
UNHCR Refugee Convention → Korea Refugee Act
Immigration
UNHCR Resettlement Program → Korea Refugee Resettlement Pilot
Immigration
UNODC/UNTOC Protocol on Human Trafficking → Korea Criminal Act & Act on Prevention of Human Trafficking
Labor & Work